The Trust has examined many issues relating to minewater and the consequences of and responses to the breaching of tailings impoundments. These usually are catastrophic in nature with local devastation to the surrounding environment and downstream of such events. Such events can have horrendous consequences including the destruction of property and in many cases loss of human life.
At least the integrity of the Mosaic gypsum stack (the name given to the waste water and material impoundment that stacks the waste as heaps which eventually dry out into a hill that might be restored to grass) was not breached laterally instead the base of the impoundment sprung a leak which developed into an enormous sinkhole that drained the stack of its water. It is still draining water and debris from the stack which will continue until it is possible to plug the hole.
The volume of water that has escaped the site has been estimated at around 240 million gallons and an unknown volume of sludges of various viscosity and liquefaction. The sinkhole has as yet only been able to be observed from the air due to the nature of the liquefied nature of the gypsum body and the danger of being drawn into the sinkhole itself.
The realisation that an event of some magnitude was taking place was when the water surface was noted to have dropped by 2 feet on 27th August when the USEPA, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection and the Polk County Authority of events: the public were not informed till 15th September when the Tampa Bay Times had a ‘leak’ from an individual. The mining company quickly stated that there was no risk to the public from the site or to the public aquifer. The neighbouring properties that receive well water were not warned by Mosaic due to attempts to contain the spill to within the site boundaries by pumping groundwater from peripheral boreholes edging the 1,600 acre site.
This event is not the first sinkhole to have drained a stack on the site, in 1994 when the site was in the name of IMC, this operation being amalgamated with other fertiliser manufacturers and agricultural multinational entities and renamed Mosaic, a similar event took place and went, largly unreported..
The dangers to the aquifer are real but appear to be addressed by the pumping of groundwater at the edge of the site from wells put in place for such an eventuality: but until a period of time has elapsed and monitoring of supply boreholes and wells confirm that all is well no chances should be taken to whitewash over the incident. The fact that the company has agreed to pay for monitoring of the wells by their own contractors is not a wise move as it does not allow for transparency of findings. The company needed to pay for an independent reporting of all findings.
Harvey Wood,
18th September 2016.

