Sorry is Easy to Say.

The English water companies have said ‘sorry’ for the millions of hours a year that raw sewage is discharged into the natural environment. They say through their umbrella organisation, Water UK, that they plan to modernise the nation’s sewers by 2030 and spend billions of pounds. This sum is likely to require the companies to borrow around £10 billion and the consequent debt will be repaid by the water companies’ customers over years of raised water bills.

In the 1970s a Labour Chancellor of the Exchequer was heard to say about the state of Britain’s rivers being full of untreated sewage, ‘there are no votes in shit’. Today the government appears to now disagree and have published their desires for greater investment on stormwater and sewage pipe overflows spewing sewage cocktails into the nations rivers and corrupting the country’s beaches.

The water companies have stated that the public watchdog, OFWAT has to approve this expenditure.   It may be fortunate that the regulator has already published a document outlining the need for such expenditure, so the water industry already knows that particular door is open. The water industry has known for the last seven years that the writing was on the wall and have found that the public have made this message has become more legible. The pandemic has made people, nearly the whole of the nation’s population has to some extent explored their local environments, particularly their rivers, streams, and waterways. They were not impressed by the way pipes appeared to be discharging not just unattractive coloured waters, but turds, condoms, panty liners and much else.

The Twittersphere has been the focus of public condemnation of the water companies who never defended their role in this issue. Keeping your head down to avoid the brickbats being their policy. They were though preparing themselves. In the last year the water companies have been recruiting staff from the Environment Agency and some river conservation groups. These recruits being well versed in the issues of sewage entering waterways from storm water outflows. They will be the fronts for the companies and will be the focus of the media, at least initially. As the projects develop it is likely company management will take credit for the companies’ resewering the nation.

Today (18th May 2023) the water companies have stated that much of the infrastructure they inherited with the privatisation of the industry dated from the 1950s or earlier: some in fact dating back to the Victorian age. In the days prior to privatisation (1989) the water boards enjoyed being able to point out that they were at times replacing water supply pipes that were constructed of butted elm trees that had been bored through to move water in streets in the 1700s.

The water industry has always played the catch-up game as each problem that befalls it. Prior to 1974 when the water boards were created water supply and sewage collection and treatment were in the hands, primarily of the local rural and urban councils (There were though some private water supply companies that had existed as some still do: South Staffs and Cambridge water companies being two). Most of these have been swallowed up by the major companies since 1990.

In 1974 the new water authorities were staffed by enthusiastic staff who worked for new organisations that were not controlled by town halls. At the time supply pipes from the street main to houses were of lead. Poisoning the customers slowly and sewage works were poisoning the rivers with wholesale pollution of near untreated sewage from sewage works entering the rivers of the land. In some extreme instances sewage works had ceased to exist and pure sewage entered rivers.

By the time the of privatisation the lead pipes had gone, sewage works were working, many though run on a shoestring were discharging good quality water to industrially polluted rivers. The industrial pollutions were cleared up by the recessions of the 1980s and 90s.  The privatised industry in its first years were still staffed by the old water board staff whose enthusiasm had a last gasp of developing better quality sewage with large investments into major city sewage works. The water companies over spent, borrowing large sums from the City or foreign banks. This last expenditure funded from corporate pawnbrokers found the industry floundering with a few years.

Some of the companies had thought if their major cities sewage was fine or they were bounded by the sea; Northumbrian Water, Welsh Water, Southern, and Southwest Water all though that the sea could take the problem and investments went into cheap longer sewage discharge pipes and they borrowed funds to diversify. Welsh Water went into the leisure industry and corporate services and failed.  The water industry had to change rapidly to avoid embarrassment and employed more accountant and not water engineers to run them.

This loss of knowledge of water in the boardrooms of water companies changed many companies’ ethic. They sold water and treated waste. The ‘service’ could in several instances be likened to selling widgets and fly tipping waste. The variation of care and knowledge has though varied greatly with some of water companies being superior to others.

One investment by one water company, Thames Water and the Thames Tideway Tunnel has spanned the whole period of change. The scheme to take more sewage away from the city to the treatment works at Crossness to the east. It was first mooted by Thames Water Board in the 1970s and was started in the initial flush of funding at privatisation as the water boards did not have access to such funds as were needed. It has seen French, German, and Australian owners walk away as borrowing has had to continue to bring the scheme to conclusion, sometime in the future. What is even more galling for Thames Water is that once that is completed another great sewer will be needed as London continues to grow.

Once one looks at the industry in detail one realises that each one has developed a model for operating but none work as the directors, or the public would wish. There needs to be a debate on the supply of both drinking and sewage treatment. Some suggest renationalisation, others freeing the system from the regulation it is constrained by. Neither is the answer, but what is? It is though clear that sorry again will not be enough.

Recommended Articles

Verified by MonsterInsights