Reforming the water sector.   

To the House of Commons  

Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Select Committee (EFRA) 

Clean Rivers Trust charity no. 1037414         

Reforming the water sector.   

To the House of Commons  

Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Select Committee (EFRA) 

January 2025.

Preface and Introduction to the Members of the Committee.    

Clean Rivers Trust was formed in 1990 as the Clean Rivers Campaign, initially to stop the pollution of the River Trent that was at that time being caused by the poorly treated sewage from the sewage treatment works at Stoke Bardolph, Nottinghamshire. This works treated and continues to treat the majority of the wastewater from the city of Nottingham. The initial approaches of the campaign were not rejected by the owners and operators of the problematic sewage works, Severn Trent Water. At that time, their agreements with OFWAT (AMP 1) on privatisation had set a tight budget limit on improvements to infrastructure such as at Stoke Bardolph which hampered the company in stopping the pollution. The National Rivers Authority in their first report on river water quality (1990) had downgraded the river downstream of the Stoke Bardolph sewage treatment works outfall into the River Trent from a grade 2 (moderate quality) river to grade 3 (polluted) river.  The Clean Rivers Campaign worked with Severn Trent to firstly get the support for new infrastructure to be put in place from the National Rivers Authority, once that was secured Severn Trent applied for a variation of their AMP 1 agreement with OFWAT. This agreement took longer but by autumn 1991 works began at the sewage treatment works that would in less the two years see the River Trent reclassified as a class two river again. At that point, many communities from across England, Scotland and Wales contacted Clean Rivers Campaign asking for help in remediating their rivers and inland waters across the UK.

At this juncture the organisation was an ad hoc group of individuals who felt that the organisation needed to be formalised as a charitable body that would work to obtain cleaner rivers, estuaries and inland waters. The Charity Commission took till May 1994 to grant Clean Rivers Trust charitable status as it felt that, at that time, campaigning was not a role needing further organisations. This was wholly acceptable to the Trustees who had already decided that the Trust would find cost effective, sustainable solutions to water quality problems and help make those solutions available to those who needed them.

The Trust has received no grant funding from government departments though over its 34 years has conducted several consultancy roles for various ministries and agencies. The Trust has worked with many industries including mining, chemical, pharmaceutical, food and beverage, including brewing, armaments, aviation, waste and recycling as well as several of the water companies. The Trust supports itself by appealing to charitable organisations and carrying out consultancy projects where possible.

Clean Rivers Trust has been consulted by government and other bodies regarding the establishment of organisations such as the Rivers Trusts and their governing body, and the Canal and Rivers Trust (none of which have any link to Clean Rivers Trust). We have worked with both over the years, helping with science and other advice when needed. The Trust will help any group or individual who has a concern regarding any river across the country, we are unique in that we never turn any person or issue away.  Individuals involved with the Trust have voluntarily helped governments in the Middle East, North and West Africa, Asia, Europe and the Americas with regard to pollution remediation methodologies and best practise. The Trust has developed strong academic links with several Universities across the UK and further afield.   

The Water Industry from 1989 to the Present Time.

The water industry across much of England and Wales is in crisis. The water companies are suffering from, in several cases been poorly managed by their parent companies at some periods of their existence in the last 25 years. This is especially true of Thames, South West, Welsh and Southern.

The governments prior to privatisation saw the need to invest large amounts of money into the industry. The quality of potable supply and even more importantly investment in sewage treatment needed urgently. The water authorities were unable to borrow money due to them being public bodies answerable to the government. Chancellors of both major parties knew the problem but could not bring themselves to budget for the funding for improvement desperately needed. One Chancellor in particular saw no votes in the treatment of sewage.

The newly privatised water companies were initially owned by many members of the public as well as corporate investors but as the value of shares rapidly increased these thousands of individuals took their profits as soon as they could.  The city found the water companies to their liking with initially a steady return and careful corporate borrowing allowing major investment in removal of several major sources of pollution which were agreed between the Nation Rivers Authority and OFWAT.

The water companies were staffed at middle and higher grade levels by those who started their careers in the Water Authorities of in the pre-1974 river boards and local authority water offices and they found privatisation a mixed blessing at best and the fact that water was privatised something of an embarrassment. This though came to change as the water companies in the 1990s started to diversify into waste handing companies: Severn Trent purchased Biffa, whilst South West Water were taken over by the Penan Group, who used the waste handling company name Terry Adams. Other water companies looked towards their other assets, Welsh Water started to invest in leisure and hotels near their reservoirs and looked to offer local authorities’ expertise in running offices and bill handling.

Some of the water companies, Thames particularly became attractive to foreign take overs. In early 2001 Thames was acquired by the German energy group RWE, who six years later when profits were not high enough sold it on to Kemble Water Holdings Ltd, a company owned by the Australian investment company, Macquarie Group. During the time, just prior to its first take over and after RWE sold to the Australians Thames Water had instigated the Thame Bubbler which pumped oxygen into the River every time it rained in the London area due to the Thames Water sewer stormwater overflows discharging raw sewage into the River Thames. This oxygenation stopped fish mortality from being visible from the Terrace of the House of Commons. Similarly, the sewage detritus was also collected upstream of Parliament by the Thames Skimmer which removed sewage related debris from the surface of the water.

Thames Water at the same time agreed with the Environment Agency to construct the Thames Tideway Tunnel that would take nearly all the sewer and stormwater overflows away from the river and transport the effluent to treatment to the east. This was considered the largest water engineering project in London since the construction of the main sewers of London in the 1870s. The costs were high and grew with and above inflation. In 2017 Macquarie divested itself of Kemble Water Holdings to Canadian and Middle East investors. This though hides the high debt the water company was faced with.

Macquarie though leaving the Uk water industry in 2017 returned taking a controlling stake in Greensand Holdings Ltd, the parent company of Sothern Water in 2021. Since then, the company has put in train a large investment package to improve many failures but by doing so has increased the company’s debt substantially.

Several water companies are carping about fines, though due to cutbacks in Environment Agency staff and expenditure there is less pressure on the water companies than in earlier years.

Welsh Water is a remarkable transformation as a not-for-profit company but is a major polluter and appearing to be forgiven by Natural Resources Wales for its inabilities to meet many of its discharge consents. Clean Rivers Trust have made comment of the company’s inabilities not to pollute and have been inundated by people and organisations supportive of the company saying they have not enough money to invest in pollution prevention or remediation and it is ‘not their fault’. The public appear swayed by a near charitable status rather than outraged about the pollution.

Predecessors.

The state was responsible for the water and wastewater for most of the urban and where public sewers were placed, rural sewage treatment from the Victorian period though much of the 20th century. The issues of pollution were not regulated till the River Boards were formed in 1946 which saw the first controls on pollution imposed on direct industrial polluters discharging waste to rivers. The local authorities being responsible for the discharge of ‘treated’ sewage as well as water supply. In rural areas septic tanks or soakaways were more common than they are today.

The local authorities gave up most of their sewage treatment works along with the supply of potable water in 1974 with the introduction of the regional waterboards. These also assumed the role of the river boards.  

In England and Wales prior to the creation of the water companies in 1989 the water supply to the population of Great Britain in the main was considered a public health issue. This recognition of public health first started to be understood from the 1850s due to the work of doctors such as Snow who identified the source of an outbreak of cholera to the polluted water coming from the Broad Street pump, Westminster, the arm of which he chained closed (1854). Prior to this outbreaks of many waterborne diseases were considered to have been brought about by a miasma, the usually foul smells from drains and rivers. At this time, the River Thames and its tributaries such as the River Fleet were little better than open sewers. This situation was initially rectified largely by the sewering of the greater part of the capital in the 1870s and 80s by the Westminster Borough Engineer Joseph Bazalgette. Most UK towns and cities followed similar ideas for their sewerage problems in the following years of the 19th Century.

The above was not the first time that polluted water was noted between pollution and concern for potable water, many cities and towns had observed the consequences of waste being deposited into waterways upstream of where water was drawn for water supply. In the Middle Ages traditionally water was removed for the City of Shrewsbury from the English Bridge over the River Severn and waste was deposited by the Welsh Bridge: The Welsh Bridge being upstream of the English. The City Authorities realised the mistake when substantial amounts of blood were seen being poured into the River Severn from the Welsh Bridge by a butcher who was incidentally fined for polluting the publics’ water: the problem being resolved simply by taking water from the Welsh Bridge and waste was disposed of from the English Bridge.

Once the local authorities and their medical officers understood the linkages between sewage and health, urban councils in the later per part of the 19th Century, prided themselves on the qualities of potable water supplied to the populations of urban and, to some extent, rural areas, though the later were often reliant on private or parish wells to supply domestic needs. The Royal Commissions into the quality of the nation’s water supplies published reports in the 1860s through to the early 1900s. These documents demonstrate the variability of water quality across the nation.

Alongside the public supply of wells initially by corporations: philanthropic and monastic foundations (such as in the City of Lincoln) private water companies made their first appearance in the 17th Century when the City of London was noted to be short of water. This first company, known as the New River Company, built a canal, known as the New River, to supply subscribers and shareholders with piped water gathered in land it acquired in southern Hertfordshire and flowed for much of its length alongside the River Lee (Lea). This conduit is still in use today.

West London in the 19th Century was also short of water and the Southwark Water Supply Company took water from the River Thames passing it through filter beds to supply a growing number of new houses and some older properties close to their premises with a piped supply. The abstraction of water from the Thames continues today from similar locations.

The regulation of rivers and their pollution was in 1989 moved to the National Rivers Authority in England and Wales whilst for Scotland the Scottish Environment Protection Agency was formed from the river boards in 1996. In England and Wales, the National Rivers Authority was merged with Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Pollution to form the Environment Agency.

Government as Supplier and Sewage Undertaker

Today several of the water companies supply water in bulk to government ministries, including the Home Office and Ministry of Defence who then supply it to old now privately owned houses and other property that were once part of their estates. Often the infrastructure is old, and, in many cases, the potable mains supply is of a substandard quality due to leakage. Ministries have worked to either get these supplies of water taken on by the water companies or find other ways to divest themselves of these problem mains.

Similarly, the ministries who own and operate sewage treatment works have managed to have their inhouse sewage works taken over or at least operated by water companies over the last 25 years though some still operate in-house due to the likely shorty term nature of contracts offered.

Local Government Sewage Treatment Works and Night Soil Collection.

With the formation of the water authorities in 1974 some local authorities kept some sewage treatment works separate and within their own estates in the belief that there was a cost benefit in certain locations. Sadly, much of the reasoning for this has been lost with the changes in local authorities and shredding of documentation. West Norfolk District Council had several such facilities which are now operated for them by Anglian Water, whilst those in Fenland District Council have a number that it maintains and is responsible for their discharge quality.

The issue of night soil collection is almost secret as individual houses that are not served by sewer or cesspit are thankfully rare. Biffa Waste Services operated the last night soil collections around several properties in Newark and Sherwood District Council area of Nottinghamshire in the 1990s. There is no knowing if any collections still take place today across the UK.

The Regulators.

The Royal Commission enquiries into Pollution of Rivers of Great Britain from 1860s to early 1900s outlined concerns regarding river pollution across the nation. Nothing though was put in place to start rectifying the situation until the 1940s with the creation of river boards which oversaw both a slight improvement in some rivers and a realisation that actions could be taken that saw river water quality change. Rivers such as the Thames with some vociferous royal patronage improved markedly. This continued with the water authorities in England and Wales and in Scotland an increase in funding allowed much to be started for the safeguarding of the riparian value of stretches of some of the major salmonid rivers.

The National Rivers Authority formed in 1989 was a turning point in England and Wales for river pollution and changes in water quality for the good. At its foundation, many rivers were as poor as they could possibly have been, the River Don was a dead river with little life apart from sewage fungi present, by the late 1990s match angling had returned to its waters.

The National Rivers Authority championed much research into pollutants they saw as fundamental to the wellbeing of aquatic life. Minewater from the then dwindling coal industry, run off from contaminated land, endocrine disrupters and their mimics. Their work in-house to produce state of catchment reports which have never been bettered, demonstrated a truthfulness that would not be tolerated by DEFRA today.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                

The Scottish Environment Protection Agency has gained from its funding from a devolved government as the government and its electorate are both smaller and more aware of the great rivers of the country. Wales has belatedly taken up the funding of Natural Resources Wales, but the variety of issues is proving to be more varied and as such requiring special funding from the Welsh Government to begin taking the lead on some historic river related issues such as metal mine spoil run off in West Wales.

The role of the Environment Agency has notably slowed down since its formation in 1996. Having joined up with HMIP. The greater base load of issues not to do with rivers, loss of staff who had worked across river catchments getting to know many rivers and streams well. What was likely to pollute them and, in many instances, taking pre-emptive action. Today the staff are younger, more qualified pre-employment and believe they know better than their forebears.

The Environment Agency has had much of its grant in aid cut back, its often incapable of swift resolution of a pollution as the is only a central laboratory which is over stretched. Pollutions have often ceased before their source has been located.

Some staff are demoralised by the lack of speed bringing about pollution prosecutions and the trading of such prosecutions altogether by the culprit donating large sums to Environment Agency designated charities like the Rivers Trusts, National Trust or Wildlife Trust. It is as if such action was a get out of prison free card.

Many discharges from sewage treatment and other sources to controlled waters are self-monitored and reliant on the possible polluter reporting their error or persistent breaches of consent to the Environment Agency or Natural Resources Wales. This has been shown to be a poorly overseen method of monitoring in relation to Welsh Water.

The Effects of the European Union and BREXIT on Rivers Across Britain.

The European Community, prior to Britain’s joining the Common Market, admired Britain’s water supply and with strong direction from the Commission many member states pre-empting the UK, using private companies to supply high quality potable water. There are though other states reliant on local authorities for supplies, these still have concerns for their tap water and rely on bottled supply.

This lack of outside funding with regard to sewage treatment across the European Union allowed for the European Commission to look at the water quality of rivers across Europe and develop a standard of assessment of river water quality, the Water Framework Directive. Much of this plan was admirable whilst some were not so good.

Britain has a regulatory framework for rivers management unique in Europe which is now based on the European regulation which it upholds as much as the Environment Agency is able whilst in European countries there are no national agencies and few local ones that uphold the law as seen across the UK. In December 2024, the European Environment Agency stated that no European nation would comply with the time scales for improved river water quality across the Union.

In 1989 the UK was demonised as the ‘Dirty Man of Europe,, by the Commissioners in Europe. This in the early 1990s was changed by a concerted effort by the water industry and regulator, but by the time the water directive came into play the water industry had changed as had the regulator.

Short Note on the Environment Agency.

The agency formed in 1996 was aware from its inception that the country was going to be bound by the Water Framework Directive which was a major issue for it to take on without its expansion into waste regulation, flood control, coastline management and much else. It also saw a cut in its funding which has continued annually. It was not allowed to be independent of DEFRA and was barred from being critical of government. It had its web site removed and is now an adjunct to gov.uk. Some of its most valuable public information is now hosted on a charity’s web site, not a role for a charity, whilst other principal elements have been lost altogether.

The State of British Rivers Today.

The state of rivers in Britain is poor. Those in England and Wales are of particular concern due to both population densities and greater ranges of identifiable pollutants entering them. Prior to water privatisation in 1989 detailed understanding of the complexities of river pollution were to a great degree masked by the gross pollutions emanating from many sewage treatment works that were overwhelmed by volumes of waste that they were not designed to treat.

We are now aware of river water pollutants; few rivers are biologically and chemically of moderate quality let alone of good quality. We are aware of the tens of thousands of hours that raw sewage flows into the rivers through various overflows that protect sewer systems from flooding homes with backed up waste. We can identify ‘for ever chemicals’ endocrine disrupters, viruses that emanate from our homes and hospitals, pharmaceuticals, both prescribed and recreational that pollute the rivers after passing through waste treatment works.  This set of issues are a series of never-ending discussions that the water companies have had with government and regulators for more than 30 years. There are ways to remove most of these pollutions, but it is the question of cost, the polluter pays being those who make or use the product who should pay for their removal. Government and regulator have not decreed.

In reality these pollutants are now removeable, and methodologies are getting less expensive, but water companies are not keen to spend money until they have to. The requirement that wastes need the Government to stipulate removal at first from those waste discharges where space is available to install tertiary treatment. It may also require the companies to be inventive in the fields of engineering, chemistry and natural science.

The Uses of Rivers.

Historically many towns and cities kept their commercial centres away from the rivers that passed through them. The river was the place of barges and industry which did little for the town apart from bring in trade and wealth to some and a poor living for many. The rivers were where rubbish and waste floated away.

Today the gentrification of the riversides in many towns and cities from London’s Canary Wharf and Thames Gateway to Gloucester Docks and Newark on Trent the reinterpreting of Leath and Cardiff docks are all making these once rundown, polluted areas places to be enjoyed and visited.

We now need to re-evaluate rivers as features or veins across and through the landscape. Natural corridors for nature as well as receivers of treated effluents. Places for leisure, swimming and boating, idling by, fishing and supplying drinking water supply..

Values of Rivers.

Nature/Biodiversity.

Water Supply.

Swimming.

Receive Treated Wastewater/Dilution.

Commercial and Recreational Craft.

Agriculture and Irrigation.

Cooling Water Supply.

Flood relief though managing catchments, wetlands, water meadows.

River Problems.

Flooding

Industrial Pollution.

Sewage raw and only partially treated (no tertiary treatment).

Agricultural Pollution.

Aerosols dissolved in rain, including road and other discharges to air.

Urban Run-off from roads and general population, litter.

Disease Vectors.

Mines:

Historic Coal mine water from old workings discharges include iron, and aluminium.

Historic Metalliferous Mining wastes including lead, cadmium and arsenic.

Diffuse Pollutions. Many small pollutions come to rivers via surface water drains, often owned by local authorities or other agencies that gather runoff from mis connected domestic appliances, or oils that home mechanics pour down drains.

Contaminated Land.

Water Future.

Water Supply of potable quality to homes and businesses and better-quality discharges from sewage treatment works to rivers are an expectation over the next years, but these gains should not be allowed to deteriorate again, as in the mid1990s.

Regulation.

Give the regulator back its independence, allow it to be critical of government and industry. Let it be funded at the required level, allow it to spend its prosecution fines on research rather than the present ‘non fine’ donations to charity.

Encourage the develop of a ‘super Fund’ as in the US to tackle contaminated land issues.

Future Water Supply and Wastewater Treatment.

Rivers are one method of recycling treated sewage, but the ‘actual’ recycling of sewage water directly to storage, preferably in open reservoirs is an accepted method in some water stressed areas such the western United States.

Water from abandoned mines that often now pollutes rivers across many parts of the UK has in the past been used to supply mining communities with household water. Clean Rivers Trust has identified several minewater resources for industry. These have included power station supply and product water. In most cases the water qualities were cheaper to bring up to specification including potable supply than water from some conventional sources.

There is a need for several new regional reservoirs across England. The cost and time spent proving need to planners and the public may be better spent looking at and accessing alternative supplies.

How the Water Industry Might Do Better.

The water companies need to plough back much of their profit to the care of potable supply and treatment of wastewater. The use of alternative supply sources should be encouraged.

The greater use of tertiary treatment at sewage treatment works to increase supply of good quality supply to the river environment. In drought conditions such as that of 2018 the flow of the River Trent was made up over 40% treated sewage. Most rivers rely on sewage treatment works to maintain summer levels of flow. Many large conurbations have major sewage treatment facilities that are running short of space as new homes and industry comes on stream. Some new sewage works might be placed to treat more locally waste cutting need of pumping waste over long distances. This would cut energy use as well as allow space to develop tertiary treatments.

The water companies should work with house builders to cut potable supply use in new homes and design such dwellings to be capable to use rainwater and grey water to be used for sanitary purposes. Similarly, the water companies may initially supply industry with process waters from separate sources such as recycled sewage.

Conclusion.

Clean Rivers Trust has followed the water industry for the last 35 years. It sees that the options for government are difficult, re-nationalisation or maintain the status quo are equally unappealing. What ever changes the water industry undergoes will be costly with government likely underwriting the changes. We see that miss management by parent companies has left one water company near bankrupt whilst another that is run as a not-for-profit company has been a major polluter over several years and is not seriously regulated by its regulator.

The government, what ever it may draw up for the future, and sooner rather than later must cover at least all the dual, supply and wastewater companies so they are governed the same way. Fragmentation of the water industry would lead to problems as time passes and a further restructuring would need to take place in a few years again.

Appendices.

Water Supply and Sewage Treatment Companies England and Wales (2025):

Company NameService AreaParent
Anglian WaterEast of EnglandInvestment Consortium
Northumbrian WaterNortheast EnglandNorthumbrian Water Group Ltd.
Severn Trent WaterEnglish Midlands, ChesterSevern Trent
Southern WaterSoutheast EnglandGreensands Holdings
South West WaterSouthwest EnglandPennon Group
Thames WaterGreater London, Thames ValleyKemble Water Limited
United UtilitiesNorthwest EnglandUnited Utilities
Dwr Cymru/Welsh WaterWest Midlands England, WalesGlas Cymru
Wessex WaterSouthwest EnglandYTL Corporation
Yorkshire WaterYorkshire and HumbersideKelda Group

Water Supply Only (2025:

CompanyService AreaParent
  Affinity WaterCentral region: Amersham, Barnet, Beaconsfield, Bishop’s Stortford, Harlow, Harrow, Hemel Hempstead, Letchworth, Luton, Saffron Walden, St Albans, Staines, Stevenage, Uxbridge, Watford, Welwyn Garden City, Woking
East region: Brightlingsea, Clacton-on-Sea, Frinton-on-Sea, Harwich, Manningtree, Wivenhoe
Southeast region: Dover, Folkestone, Hythe, Romney Marsh, Dungeness, Lydd
Allianz/HICL Infrastructure/DIF Tamblin
Albion WaterKnowle Village (Hampshire), Oaklands Hamlet (Chigwell), Upper Rissington (Gloucestershire)Albion Water Group
Bourn-emouth WaterBournemouth, Christchurch, Lymington, Ringwood, Verwood, Wimborne MinsterPennon Group
Bristol WaterBristol, Burnham-on-Sea, Frome, Tetbury, Wells, Weston-super-MarePennon Group
Cambridge Water CompanyCambridge, St IvesSouth Staffordshire Water
Cholder-ton and District Water CompanyAmport, Bulford, Cholderton, Quarley, Shipton Bellinger, ThruxtonCholderton Estate
Essex and Suffolk WaterEssex region: Basildon, Brentwood, Chelmsford, Southend-on-Sea, Thurrock, Barking and Dagenham, Havering, Redbridge
Suffolk region: Aldeburgh, Eye, Great Yarmouth, Lowestoft, Southwold
Northumbrian Water Group Ltd.
Hartle-pool WaterHartlepoolAnglian Water
Ports-mouth WaterBognor Regis, Chichester, Fareham, Gosport, Havant, Hayling Island, PortsmouthAncala
South East WaterEastern region: Ashford, Canterbury, Eastbourne, East Grinstead, Haywards Heath, Maidstone, Sevenoaks, Tonbridge, Royal Tunbridge Wells, Whitstable. Western region: Aldershot, Basingstoke, Bracknell, Camberley, Maidenhead, Petersfield, WokinghamUtilities Trust of Australia/Desjardins Group/NatWest Group Pension Fund
South Staffordshire WaterAldridge, Brownhills, Burton upon Trent, Cannock, Kinver, Lichfield, Rugeley, Sutton Coldfield, Tamworth, Uttoxeter, Walsall, West BromwichSouth Staffordshire Water Company  
Sutton and East Surrey WaterCobham, Dorking, Horley, Leatherhead, Oxted, Redhill, Reigate, SuttonPennon Group
Youl-grave Water-works  YoulgraveIndependent non-profit
Hafren DyfrdwyWrexham, PowysSevern Trent

Scotland.

Water is supplied and treated by Scottish Water, part of the Scottish Government.

NOTE:

Appendices   

(In part Wikipedia, Water Companies in England and Wales)

Recommended Articles

Verified by MonsterInsights