
Has the polluted minewater returned?
For much of May, June and the first part of July this year there has been a notable lack of ochre water entering the harbour via the Bransty Beck. Enquiries by sailors and others have been assured by Network Rail, Mining Remediation Authority and Environment Agency that the pollution had ceased and that there was no specific reason for the cessation of minewater. A shorter period of no flow from the mine workings has though happened before, in June last year (2025) when the harbour returned to near normal water conditions. Last year’s short break from this acidic pollution ceased the day of our visit to see the change. This longer respite ceased on 12th July in the afternoon (picture above).
The image below was taken on 10th July in the afternoon. The lack of ochre is quite obvious. The only ochre is the staining of the harbour wall and its reflexion on the water surface.
Clean Rivers Trust, Sellafield, the local authorities, plus the Environment Agency, Mining Remediation Authority and Network Rail were brought together to form a Task Force by the local MP to seek out solutions. This was achieved successfully, but due to a retired railway engineer’s understanding of acoustics while travelling through the Bransty Tunnel. He diagnosed a void beneath the tracks was developing. He contacted both Network Rail and the safety Executive as a matter of urgency and shortly after the tunnel was closed on the 25th July 2025.
The Task Force is now made up of the three major players, The Environment Agency, Mine Remediation Authority and Network Rail. The new Task Force is finding easier to manage the media interest in the issues.

The Tunnel.
The modified task force have spoken little to the media and there is little detail as to plans from the group. It was remarkable to have a copy of this article, published on the Home Page of the ‘Branch Line Society’.
‘Whitehaven (Bransty) Tunnel: (BLN 1494 1149) NR is proposing to temporarily close this single track 1,283yd tunnel until 17 May 2027 (de facto closed since 26 Jul 2025), which saves Business Rates. In 2020, water from disused mines (there are many) started to enter the tunnel, flooding part of it and covering the rail head. This is thought to have occurred due to a partial collapse of old mine workings below, impacting the flow of ground and mine water. Track and drainage renewal was planned and developed throughout 2022 and 2023, with implementation planned in 2024. Surveys were completed and identified significant voids beneath the tunnel with a reasonable to high risk of tunnel collapse. NR undertook an assessment which resulted in the immediate closure of Bransty Tunnel on safety grounds. The Whitehaven Task Force was established and has been progressing a remediation solution.
NR is ready to mobilise and deliver the tunnel recovery (now costed at £50M and Government funded). All engineering, design and delivery elements are in place. Work cannot start without resolution of the regulatory position on mine water discharge and long term liability. 15 permits and consents are needed for work to take place and the Taskforce is currently working through the application process for these.
The works require historic mine working stabilisation. This is completed by drilling and grout infill of both the Main and Yard Coal seams beneath the tunnel. This will prevent the worst case scenario, collapse of the historic mine workings and Bransty Tunnel. The drill and grout infilling will be in sectionalised grout cells. A trial cell will check the grout mix, injection method, pressures, returns and verification criteria.
The works include installation of pressure relief wells and an associated drainage system connected to the existing Bransty Beck outfall to manage and contain the trackbed water flows. The ¾ mile of track and its drainage will then be renewed between Corkickle and Whitehaven to enable the line to reopen.
The protracted closure of Bransty Tunnel has seriously impacted Cumbrian Coast services, as the line is closed between Whitehaven and Corkickle until, it seems, at least May 2027. Northern Carlisle services turnback at Whitehaven and Barrow-in-Furness services at Corkickle, with a replacement bus between.’

Bransty Tunnel.
Going Forward.
The coal seams beneath Whitehaven are all linked at some point with some workings linked to seams worked beneath the Irish Sea as well as those below the town and surrounding area. Issues such as tide and gas movement as well as those of permissions to discharge to sea or stream are areas of contention alongside the need of the railway industry and their customers including Sellafield wishing to safely travel along the tunnel length.
The Coal Authority who championed the idea of taking the minewater pollution away from the harbour and discharging the material on the North Shore in a similar operation to that at Parton beach. This scheme having been operational for fifty years. This was the least costly option and prices for treating and discharging to a United Utility sewer would be the next least expensive. The added water flow through the wastewater treatment woks might be considered of some value to the utility company.
Sadly, United Utilities did not want to get involved with the problem and did not offer expert guidance even though they were asked. There office in Whitehaven is less than a stone’s throw from the station and the tunnel entrance.
The MP continues to press the agencies for action and is excellent in keeping his constituents informed but it must be unpleasant pushing three government independent bodies to agree on any plan readily or with a modicum of haste.
The Trust has outlined a low-cost solution, but no answer has been forthcoming from any of the ‘Task Force’
We will keep you updated as soon as we hear of anything.