EU Science Paper Questioned.

The following paper appeared out of EU Science for Environment Policy Directorate this week, it has no background information as to who was involved or where the research was carried out. The paper appears to delight in raising concerns for the use of constructed wetlands, particularly those used for the treatment of nitrate rich wastewaters such as might come from sewage treatment works and some agricultural processes such as anaerobic digestion. Both waste waters being suitable sources for nano plastic pollution. The plastic used was polystyrene. The paper demonstrates some issuers that need to be looked at but as it states in its text the results may be brought about by other mechanisms that were not being monitored.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

due to its surface texture and ability to coat, clog surfaces. It is also the least likely to enter root systems of wetland plants such as Typha in a gravel bed as the plastics would naturally float buoyantly, riding the surface of the wastewater.

The constructed wetland was apparently created for the experiment and its condition was not described. No mention of development of microbial populations or priming of the wetland at any point prior the first 45 days of monitoring.

Clean Rivers Trust research polystyrene in soils and wetlands 25 years ago as an alternative growing media addition for treatment wetlands. The material used was large, anchored blocks as base material and as barriers or riffles within the wetland. The polystyrene was shown to host many beneficial microbial bacterial growths. These acted as both a nutrient bank for the Typha being used in our experiments that restored vigour to the plants overloaded with several contaminants. and similarly acted as a co participant in nutrient removal. Typha were also able to break apart the plastic blocks with root contractions and even by burrowing over time (the experiments lasted some 2.5 years). The apparent decline in Typha vigour in the EU reported experiment would have needed to have been in exceptionally slow flows and run through the wetland gravel beds at less capacity than the loading design to develop significant choke the system.

In the 1970s the use of perlite in plant growing media was popular, both to avoid the plant desiccation in transport and cut back on peat use in potting. In the 1980s and 90s polystyrene was used as to cut shipping weight of plants and reduce peat use. In some cases, such high volumes were used that plant vigour was fatally impaired due to the root systems being unable to gain nutrition from the scant soils.

The time frame in the research carried out noted that the plastics adhered to the microbial structures within the wetland, thus impairing the electron transport system thus reducing nutrient take up. The loading levels of plastic being increased significantly during the period of research adding to the problem during the time allowed for the research found the wetland provide the desired results.

If such an experiment were run with 4 waste streams in tandem over the same time period, I believe the results would have been fundamentally different and at the end of 6 months the wetlands would have demonstrated the ability of such constructed systems to be resilient and able to continue removing nutrients as desired and at the same time remove the plastics from the feed water.

It is worth remembering that each wastewater needs to be designed for, the off the peg design is never the real answer, this is true for all constructed wetlands from treating sewage derived effluents to minewater. Each needs to be individually assessed and catered for.

Plastic is the problem of the moment and much research is aimed to demonstrate its demon status.

Recommended Articles

Verified by MonsterInsights