The desire of many people in England and Wales is that the next government should take the water companies back into public ownership, this though may not be as desirable or as straight forward an issue as one might think. The future of water supply and sewage treatment are critically important in the time of climate chaos, global warming, and growing population. Drinking water quality has also now appeared as an issue in many people’s purview and raised as another failing of the privatised water industry.
Sewage.
The reason for this is that the Water Companies are seen to be the major factor for river water quality being so poor, with most rivers in the two nations being reported by the Environment Agency as being in decline and no river is unpolluted. The number of discharges from combined storm water overflows that discharge untreated sewage and rainwater into rivers is now available to the public and even in a wet period these overflows are running more often than it rains. The reasons being several for this including rebound of groundwater, old, poorly jointed sewer pipes that in dry times leak to the ground or in the very wet times allow raised groundwater to enter the sewers, new housing and other developments discharging to sewers overwhelmed by development and underdevelopment of the sewer networks.
The majority of sewage treatment works discharge well treated water to their consented qualities. Many though could still produce better quality discharge water if they used tertiary treatment methods, but often, due to space constraints this is impossible at their present locations. This is true in thousands of sewage treatment plants in villages particularly.
Most combined storm water discharges to rivers and streams are consented by the Environment Agency to protect the public from sewage backing up thus defiling peoples’ homes and streets with sewage. The sewerage when discharged from these safety valves within the system are meant to only operate at times of severe rain precipitation, though the data demonstrates that many overflows function for much longer. This then demonstrates that much of the sewage infrastructure is either lacking maintenance or is undersized and infrastructure needs to be increased in size.
United Utilities has set up a team of Water Rangers to explain to the public that the pollution from their waste water treatment works at Bowness is not the companies fault and that it is brought about by tourism and the abundance of wildfowl on the water. The sewage problems would be solved if tourists did not visit the Lake District.
Drinking Water.
In the United Kingdom potable supply has been a proud boast for all who travelled abroad for many decades that the country had the best quality drinking water in the world. It is still amongst the best for drinking and washing uses globally. In a recent taste test Britain came 13th of over 100 nations offering samples for judgement.; the best coming from Iceland.
Unfortunately for the water industry, South West Water managed this May (2024) to serve its customers in the Brixham area of Devon a cocktail of gastrointestinal bacteria which had found their way into an underground reservoir holding the town’s potable supply. Many people in the area have become extremely ill. This event is just under 36 years (July 1988) since South West Water Authority were responsible for the poisoning of a number of people in the Camelford area of Cornwall. The earlier event was caused when a delivery of aluminium sulphate was put in the wrong part of a drinking water treatment plant by a delivery driver so making the level of the chemical 3000 time greater than what at the time was admissible. Remarkably South West Water is the only regional water authority/company to have had such events take place in their region. Regarding both incidents the senior management initially denied the emergencies even though their staff on the ground new otherwise and were reporting back to their management.
Sothern Water also has made the headlines of the media by having a mains pipe supplying Hastings with drinking water disintegrate. The company has twice received planning permission for a new main but both have lapsed due to lack of finance.
Background.
The twin issues of sewage pollution and the pollution of drinking water demonstrate that something is wrong with the industry, but as with any regional monopoly that is not nationalised is that it cannot be controlled, or its business model is unable to be prescribed by government in any major way.
Dennis Heally when he was Chancellor of the Exchequer in the 1970s stated that there were no votes in sewage. I am not sure if the reality has changed that much today. The media are delighted to quote the many voices critical of the water companies. Many critics of the industry state the need for the water companies to be prosecuted and fined fined heavily. The straightforward view that the companies should cut profits to shareholders and spend these millions of pounds on upgrading the sewage infrastructure. The media influence the agenda for the water industry.
Prior to the 1989 privatisation of the water industry the view of many world governments who were aware that as they aimed to bring their nations up to a higher environmental standard Britain’s river water quality was declining. Britain was appearing to be the ‘Dirty Man of Europe’. The British government was also well aware of the situation. The water Authorities formed in 1974 had done an incredible job in their early years resurrecting sewage treatment works from overgrown thickets of trees and shrubs, and building extensions to those sites that were not treating beyond sieving the waste before discharging the raw sewage to rivers. The rivers were fortunate in that their environmental well being was removed from the old river boards and incorporated within the same water authorities. This allowed for the first time an ease of access between a regulator and a sewage undertaker and meant that they needed to operate together..
Before the 1974 changes that formed the water authorities the river boards has little chance to influence the sewage undertakers who were the local authorities, urban and rural councils, borough and city administrations who financed the treatment of water supplied to the public and treated the sewage of a proportion of their populations sewage through the ‘rates’ every household paid. Whilst drinking water quality was often an issue of civic pride the sewage was not on the same scale and was to a great extent neglected. Many councils only considered the rivers as a health concern and passed more bye laws to ban swimming or bathing to stop such epidemics as cholera in the early 20th century and polio in the 1950s.
In 1989 the newly privatised water companies were released from working with their regulators, often in the same buildings. The sudden loss of partners in producing treated sewage was quickly missed, but prior to the severing of connections a large number of schemes had been planned and these took years to be put in place due to AMP1 the first funding agreement with the regulator OFWAT who judge pricing to customers and loan agreements with the banks who were able for the first time since the 1830s (Southwark Water Supply Company Thames drinking water abstraction scheme) to fund water infrastructure in England and Wales. They also influenced the returns to the investors in new water industry for a while.
The water regulator and river guardian, the National Rivers Authority were initially phased by their being cut off from any behind the scenes influence they had with the old water authorities but soon decided to look towards setting base lines of knowledge as to the quality of rivers and the main influences on river water quality. Once that started they began to develop a new regulatory rapport with the privatised water industry with much joint research and development. Again, though the regulatory regime changed on 1st April 1996 when the National Rivers Authority were amalgamated with Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Pollution and other entities to form the Environment Agency. As the Environment Agency changed its role more towards that of policeman and looked away from forward thinking the need to change river classification came about and new parameters were introduce (a good thing in our view)in 2019 with the remarkable realisation for the Environment Agency that no river in the country was not free from chemical pollution. Much of that ‘new’ pollution could still be, if not blamed per se but it was coming from sewage treatment works. Much of these pollutants were background fabric of modern life. Pharma products, plastics, and residues of amongst other things flame retardants.
The Water Companies into the 2000s.
The water companies all developed separate models of working, some had too due to poor judgement and boardroom decisions; Welsh Water had to free itself of over diversification and became a ‘not for profit’ company to benefit its customer base, though as of recent note not the environment with many sewage works not managing to comply with their discharge consents for in some cases years on end.
North West Water became United Utilities offering to supply energy as well as water. Anglian Water looked towards the hoped-for breakdown of the regional monopolies as did several others, Severn Trent, Thames, Northumbrian, Yorkshire (part of Kelda Group). Also, the water companies vied for Ministry of Defence contracts for the care of sewage services, Coal Authority minewater treatment site, Prison Service contracts and much besides. At the turn of the Millenium a number of water companies were aggressive and wanting to be seen at the forefront of the industry whilst others were happy to not raise their ambitions or were taken over as part of a bigger concern.
The Australian investment group MacQuarrie is the best-known group from outside the UK who has run a water company in England though many other nations have been involved from France and Germany. Thames Water suffered the worst as it is now struggling for its survival after the Australian company abandoned the company in debt. The present plight of Sothern Water is not fully appreciated due to an injection of Antipodean finance. The remarkable lack of public awareness though makes the whole industry squirm.
Who Else Owns Sewage Treatment Works.
The British Government’s Estates, MoD, Prison Service, Home Office, Local Authorities own an unknown number including 20 in Cambridgeshire, operated by Fenland Borough Council, An unknown number of institutions, industries and private companies and estates. Many of which are in poor condition. Anglian Water took over one at Castle Acre in Norfolk and rather rebuild it has put in a three-mile pipeline and pumping stations to take the effluent to its treatment works at Swaffham.
The reason there are so many local authorities with sewage treatment works in their ownership is that in 1974 councils were given the option to hold back sewage treatment works in their ownership rather than pass them on to the newly created water authorities. Some councils shed them all others kept a number back thinking that they would be putting in developments at those sites and would save money by not having to pay the water authorities fees. Once these developments had been sewered the hope was that the sewage treatment works could then be transferred to the authority. For any number of reasons, the transfers never took place.
Why have the Water Companies Not Put in New Sewers?
It is a major investment for new sewage systems to be put in place, the finances of schemes are not the issue. The problems are immense with the setting up of a scheme. On at Newark on Trent conducted by Severn Trent took far longer than the residents (customers) would have wished but the organisations who had to be involved regarding routes, road closure, archaeologists, local authority planners, and many others makes a nightmare of what should be a straight forwards engineering project.
Most towns across the country actually need new part or whole sewage systems put in place.
Are Water Companies Past Their Sell by Date?
The water companies did what Mrs Thatcher (The architect of the water industry privatisation) wished for. Which was to improve sewage treatment and ensure that most drinking water remained of high quality.
Today one company is a not for profit, another is fiscally embarrassed whist another is being investigated by the Environment Agency about more than 100 pollution events and has already been fined several million pounds. All the water companies need to remove combined stormwater discharges and look towards tertiary treatment for more sewage treatment works.
The ownership issue for the industry has fractured and as with each time of water industry change since the 17th century 30 to 40 years is the time for change.
Going Forward.
Water is a major issue to all people across the globe, private companies owning a national asset is not popular to many of the population.
We all sign up to diversity and there are many options that would allow the water companies to continue as they are but without the loss of profit to shareholders, especially where dividends sent abroad.
There though must be a level playing field for the industry. Share holders may be in part HM Government or other body and no one entity can own it without shareholders. The freedom for shareholders to speak at AGMs is a safety valve for concerns.
There is a need for a national debate to understand option going forward, but it must ensure it ensures the environment and customers come first and profits are modest at best.
