The Trust visited Whitehaven on the 30th September looking forward to seeing the now clean water in the harbour. This we did at 11.00 but by 12.30 it was turning ochreous and by 14.30 it had returned to its pre clean up condition.
At lunchtime that day Network Rail had sent out to a select few (not Clean Rivers Trust) a notice that they were stopping the cleaning of the minewater emanating from the railway tunnel due to lack of funding with the hope that the permanent answer may be in place by April 2026. (Notice attached below.)
The photographs demonstrate the dramatic change in the harbour over a 3.5 hour time frame.
11.00


12.30


14.30


The Notification of Cessation of Pumping and Water Clean Up.
‘Dear all,
As you are aware, our additional ground investigations – to better understand the sub-surface conditions in the area around Bransty tunnel ahead of our specialist cement void filling work – started this week. Once complete, the previously planned track and drainage renewal can start, and then trains will resume services through the tunnel after Spring next year.
We are nearing the end of the on-site part of these ground investigations, and will be moving to the design stage to work up the final delivery plan. While we do that, we won’t be physically on-site investigating the tunnel. This means that the pumping system – which is filtering the mine water from the tunnel into the harbour as part of permit conditions from the Environment Agency for the track and drainage renewal – is no longer required at this time. As such, we plan to switch off the pumps tomorrow – Tuesday 30 September.
With the filtering system proving to be effective in the harbour, we fully recognise switching it off will not be popular. The reason why we have discounted the filtering system as a long-term measure to address the water colour is down to the prohibitive cost. Running the pumping system until the very end of the work in Spring 2026 would cost additional £4.8m. We’d need to find this money from other sources which would significantly impact our safety critical renewal and maintenance work across the NW. That said, the pumps will remain in situ and be switched on again, as required by the Environment Agency, when we start our remediation works in the tunnel in early November this year.
All of this goes to highlight the important of our collective efforts on the Whitehaven Harbour Feasibility Working Group (WHFWG) and we look forward to reviewing the feasibility report when it is ready.
With thanks
of Communications
North West route
This notice implies that if the Environment Agency have agreed to the continuance of the pollution for the present time thus agreeing to the continuance of pollution once it had ceased in contravention of the Environmental Permitting Regulations, 2016.
- Causing or Knowingly Permitting: The legal test for pollution liability in the UK uses the phrase “cause or knowingly permit”.
- Causing: This means being actively involved in an operation that results in pollution.