ENERGY MINING: Minewater as Geothermal Energy

Preamble.

Clean Rivers Trust and Minewater Issues.

Since Clean Rivers Trust was formed in 1990 it has been involved in minewater issues with regard to its management, utilisation, potential and actual pollution and its mitigation. This has led to involvement in the many sorts of mining; predominantly coal and metal. The Trust has been committed to research in this area with both the mining companies including; Midland Mining, UK Coal, Scottish Coal, Anglo American Goldfields, Wheal Jane and South Crofty. It has worked closely with the Coal Authority and DECC (Dti). The Trust has ongoing projects with both the Royal School of Mines (Imperial College, London) and Camborne School of Mines (Exeter University).

The Trust has carried out work in this area in the UK, Europe and Middle East.

Concept History.

In 1988 Ropak Can Am Ltd, a manufacturer of plastic packaging products began using geothermal energy from floodwater in abandoned mines beneath their site in Springhill, Nova Scotia, Canada. The purpose was for the heating and cooling of the factory and its processes. This was the first recorded use of this technology in Canada and is now considered to be the first full scale operation worldwide. The initial energy saving to the company was 600 MWh per annum. The initial cost of installation was C$110,000, compared with C$70,000 for a conventional combustion heating system; the company though saved C$110,000 on the need to install dehumidifiers for its production process.

The resource of the minewater that was used was at a temperature of 18 degrees C. and was pumped originally to the surface at 4 litres per second. The return flow water was at 13 degrees C.. The return water was routed to a different, deeper mine though interlinked below ground.

The project was reported in CADDET publicity at the time, but internationally the power generating companies were involved in the ‘dash for gas’ and the project has been forgotten. The community of Springhill has though developed the local capability to utilise this heat source; public buildings, further industrial development and private residences all now utilise this resource.

Twenty-first Century Developments.

In 2005 the technology was rediscovered by a mining consultancy based in the Netherlands; Reming Lowex of Maastricht who put together a successful bid for EU funding to build a small scale power station at Heerlen in the south of Holland. The funding was as a demonstration project in collaboration with local government in France and Germany (Lorraine and Alsace).

Heerlen.

The southern area of Holland was a traditional coal mining region that closed down in the 1950s when indigenous gas reserves were found and proved to be more economic than coal. The Heerlen Mine closed in 1959.

The power station operates on two levels; a supplier of warm water to the district as a heating and refrigeration resource and also a power generator of electricity. The use of the old shafts for the water take for the power generation was chosen as it was a local and national priority redevelopment site. Five boreholes were also drilled to access the mine workings at a depth of 700 metres for district heating with a pumped capacity 80 cubic metres of water per hour. Water temperature at the bottom of the boreholes is 32 degrees C. declining to 28 degrees at the surface and passed through heat pumps before being returned to the mine environment. In summer water of a lower temperature can be used when less heating is necessary for homes. This lower temperature supply is accessed at 250 metres depth.

The economics of the scheme do not show much variation from heating costs prior top the project coming on line but the operator has guaranteed a fixed price over a long period. Environmentally there has been a drop of 55% in CO2 emitions.

The electrical generation side of the project is not publically available at this juncture but is generating over 2 MWs.

Other Regions of Development.

In Europe the development is being led by the Central Europe Development Fund to aid coalmining communities who have lost economically due to mine closure. Though led by central European Countries the funding appears to be spreading out to other economies in the EU.

  • Slovenia; the Zasavje region has started the development of four project.
  • Austria; the development of district heating schemes in two areas.
  • Germany /France border area.
  • Poland/Germany; Silesian coal field.
  • Spain; the Asturia region.

In Canada the concept has found fresh support and is being developed for use in old mining areas above the Arctic Circle as well as Nova Scotia and British Columbia.

The United States is developing schemes in many of the old coal mining area.

UK Potential.

 

The coal mining areas of the country span much of the industrial areas and major conurbations of the north and centre of the England. The coal mining areas of Somerset and Kent also appear of economic interest, as do the coalfields of south and north Wales. The potential for the operation of power and district heating schemes is large; the volumes of water in some parts of the Central Belt and to the west around Ayr deserve attention.

The metalliferous mining areas of the south west of England, west Cumbria, Anglesey and Scotland all have an abundance of water at temperatures up to 40 degrees C.

Methods.

Methods of gaining the heat from the minewater within the old workings are either by the remaining shafts; these are few and may be in inappropriate locations or preferably by borehole. The access to the water needs to be in as close a proximity to its intended purpose as is possible. The borehole into the worked seam below allows for this close proximity to the end use. The accuracy of reading old mine plans and the site of the bore hole drill; its operation, especially if having to pass through several sets of workings and the lining / casing of the hole are critical. Such expense can lead to poor results as to the economics of the venture.

The removal of the heat from the water is all known technology and though improving all the time is understood.

Legal Issues.

There may be legal issues concerning water ownership, permissions to enter workings, agreements with the Coal Authority and landowners. The mineral rights of metal mines and in areas such as the Forest of Dean; Gale ownership or the Deputy Gaveller may lead to complications.

The Environment Agency may wish to discuss the abstraction of water and the disposal of waste when the operation is in reality the retrieval and return of water that has not left a closed system.

Harvey Wood

5th September 2012.

Recommended Articles

Verified by MonsterInsights