Background.
The development of a scheme under the EU Intereg III B NWE program was between the Municipality of Heerlen in south eastern Holland (Netherlands) and Midlothian Council in the central belt south of Edinburgh, Scotland.
Two non governmental organisations were involved; in Holland Weller Wonen a housing association and the UK based Building Research Establishment (BRE). This initial grouping developed between 2003 and 2005 when the agreements were signed up to the Intereg Partnership Agreement in 2005 to include the Municipality of Bonen (Germany), Wirtshaftsfordenungsgesellschaft, Kreis Aachen mbH (WFG Germany), Bureau de Recherches Geologiques et Minieres (BRGM France) as the project progressed other interested parties from Belgium (particularly the Government of Flanders), Germany and France took monitoring and developmental roles, as did some Polish and other states.
The close proximity of the German and French to the Netherlands partner in the scheme with the Scottish section of the partnership more distant and increasingly constrained by budgetary costs in networking and sharing ‘gossip and general mundanities regarding issues of regard put a strain on the UK participation almost immediately.
The Initial Project Outline.
The project had two initial planned outputs of heat/power generation plants that were to be located in the Netherlands and Scotland. These were to be the culmination of the feasibility study of the viable heat sources to be gained from the minewater at the two areas to be investigated. Heerlen had several old mine shafts and in Midlothian the Monktonhall Colliery site was already being pumped for the management of minewater pollution.
The Dutch perspective was to reinvigorate a town that had been economically and socially damaged by the closure of its mines in the 1950s when Holland developed its own natural gas reserves rather than its small coal field which bordered Germany with its cross border issues that limited national mining reserves of supply. In Scotland the Monktonhall colliery was something of a fairytale pit which closed under the UK governments pit closure initiative of the early 1990s and reopened with the investment of the miners redundancy payments going in to encouraging outside investment to allow the mine to reopen and function for a further few years until its final closure and minewater pollution remediation put in place in 1998.
The councils of Midlothian and Edinburgh had developed a plan with the backing of the Scottish government to develop a new town, Shawfair on the site of the old colliery that would be a centre of habitation (4800 homes), employment and industrial regeneration.
The Midlothian Council and the Scottish Government commissioned at least two reports on the value and feasibility of the scheme from PB Power. These excellent and far reaching documents overview the use of minewater as a resource across the UK as well as in Scotland; they give an outline of mining in the region but question the use of the Monktonhall site when there are so many others that might be researched further. The authors also consider in the reports the energy per person employed underground compared to what would be produced from the minewater; not really comparable or relevant but a sidelight. The writers understanding of Scottish history is questionable and as it was fed into the application for EU funding Henry VIII dissolution the monastic houses of Scotland as he did in England though there was no union at that time. The end of monasteries in Scotland was the Act of Annexation passed by James VI of Scotland in 1587. In Scotland the religious houses did not have the influence, wealth or land that their southern counterparts had and was an issue of creed rather than greed.
Midlothian Council had planned to use the grant aid under the Intereg carefully, and not to drill into the shafts at the mine but to access the water that was being pumped from one of the shafts to avoid minewater pollution in the area.
The shaft which is over 900 metres deep and the water level kept at the 100 metres level pumping at an average rate of 98 litres per second. One and two pumps being used to achieve this. The minewater once on the surface being treated actively and then through a reedbed lagoon system. (Brown, Barley and Wood, 2002) the scheme proposed to access this water by using a closed loop through a heat exchanger and pump to capture the heat before the initial treatment of the water. This would have had water at a varying temperature depending on the seasonal variability of 13 to 17 degrees centigrade.
The costs of the minewater treatment scheme to the Coal Authority had been £297,000 (1998) and the running costs were at the time of the proposed heat exchange scheme £97,260 per annum (Brown et al 2002).
The proposal was at the outset of the minewater project was agreed with the EU the Midlothian Council planned to supply 500 of the proposed housing units with geothermal heat from the Monktonhall minewater discharge water.
The cost of putting in the heat metre so as to be able to bill the householders was estimated at a cost of over £900 per property; this totalled in excess of £450,000, this instillation did not include telemetry to allow remote reading. The estimated whole project has not been made public but officials from both Edinburgh and Midlothian have stated independently estimates for the project in excess of £5 million. This economic equation appeared to be excessive and was a greater sum than that estimated for sinking a pair of deep boreholes and installation of a closed loop water circuit and heat pumps which was £1.2 million.
Conclusion.
Midlothian Council were as a body uncertain as to the amount of public financial investment that they would need to put in to the proposed scheme, on top of the EU grant that was for less than 50% of the initiative, the social need could not be argued as the City Council of Edinburgh were to partner the council in developing the new town. By 2005/6 Midlothian Council bowed out of the research project and discussions started to follow lines of private development rather than a councils led scheme. In 2010 the cities formally declared their partnership dissolved and the Showfair town project was abandoned. The site is now being developed by private property companies.
Post Abandonment.
The Midlothian Council clamed that as there was no real backing for the project from the Scottish government in that there was no true plan to develop geothermal energy sources in the Scottish or UK’s strategic plans for their alternative energy portfolios: they were isolated from essential support at that crucial time. Since the abandonment of the minewater proposal the Scottish Government has developed a strategic interest but has not published any plan or guidance for production. The UK government have said little on the subject except acknowledge that in theory it exists.
In National Science Week 2012 British Geological Survey supported CRT in announcing that there was a vast reserve of energy available in the nations’ abandoned mines in the form of minewater at the British Scientific Association’s Alternative Energy Event at Aberdeen University on 7th September. At this event BGS stated that 40% of Glasgow could be heated by this means.
Netherlands and Beyond.
The rest of the minewater utilisation project was a great success with a heat/power generating scheme now commissioned in Heerlen. The French, German, Slovakian and Polish governments are looking to copy and refine the technology further over the coming few years.
Harvey Wood
October 2012.
