The political adage that ‘there are no votes in shit’ can and has been attributed to Dennis Healy, Chancelor of the Exchequer in the 1970s. It was the nearest one might have heard a Labour politician agree to the need of privatisation of the water industry. The start of the saga which is now making headlines with the privatised water companies being fined millions of pounds and most being designated as not fit for purpose.
This is not a political rant: Margaret Thatcher and the Conservative government privatised the water authorities in 1989. The water companies were to deal with the horrendous state of the rivers in the UK, pollution flowed from a great number of sewage treatment works that were hopelessly overwhelmed by the increasing volumes of wastewater that was being presented to them. The country had never realised that the water companies were treating sewage. Water was drinking water that flowed from our taps. Water was pure in the UK; foreign countries drank bottled water and only washed in their rather iffy tap water. The privatisation of the water companies always played up to Britain’s tap water quality, it never mentioned the waste waters element and the politicians kept very quiet until after the deed was done. Large numbers of the general public bought shares, and none knew the sewer systems and sewage works were in melt down: not that they cared as the majority of citizen shareholders sold their issue of shares swiftly taking a huge profit. The water companies were at the time run by water people, though Severn Trent’s Chairman Vic Cocker (brother of Joe Cocker the singer) who started life as a gas board man.
The water company management had come up through the industry with apprentices and sponsored university places. The first ten years saw an almost socialist view of spending by some of the water companies. Sewage works were upgraded and rivers and coastal discharges from sewers improved remarkably. Along side this spending saw the dire consequences for many working people with economic decline for manufacturing industries. Many factories closed and unemployment numbers grew. The closure of factories did help the environment, with many discharges polluting rivers and canals stopped. In a few years the River Tame which drained a major part of Birmingham and the Black Country came from the most polluted river in England and which could not sustain any aquatic life, to a river with a developing diverse ecology.
It is sad that other parts of the country did not fair so well with their water companies, Welsh Water seemed to go mad, diversifying into tourism and office services which failed and eventually became a not-for-profit concern. Southwest Water senior staff kept telling me that they did not put raw sewage out to sea. This was in the face of irrefutable evidence supplied by Surfers Against Sewage. The company felt that they were still suffering from the Camelford poisoning of drinking water before privatisation. The board complained that it was being slandered and misunderstood. Their legal department though agreed with Surfers Against Sewage.
Yorkshire Water in the early days demonstrated their newfound freedom as a public company by bringing sewage discharges of many of their rivers up to a water quality not seen since the start of the industrial revolution. Wessex was interesting in that they were to shy or did not wish to do anything publicly and still appear the same today. Southern Water started to encourage their scientific staff to experiment with improving sewage discharges to sea. This experimental time though did not last long enough to make the impact that those staff involved needed.
Sadly, all such individuality ceased by the end of the 1990s, many of the water companies were by then led by accountants and those with qualifications in business studies. Few if any members of boards of directors had any link to the water industry. The water companies were making good profits and the new style of management were looking at ways to expand their reach and grow profits, The mention of deregulation was brought to the fore by the industry along with MoD sites. the scurry to gain defence establishments cost the industry dear. It also saw odd companies, left over from historic anomalies such as Hartlepool Water taken over by Anglian. Water companies started changing their names, Northwest Water was the first as it got involved with power generation and became United Utilities. Yorkshire Water became Kelda, and new companies were formed to join in the deregulation.
The government offered cross border industrial companies up for grabs to the water companies, but only if the out of region company could supply the previous supplier with same volume water compensation as there could be no new cross boundary water connections. The government did not offer the sewerage up for competition. We helped the Home Office off load some Prison Estates off to their regional companies such as Anglian and Severn Trent which stopped some long-term pollutions. This competition never really worked, and the water companies suddenly became attractive to another form of ownership, firstly utilities from Europe who saw the profits made in England as of value to their bottom line and their shareholders in Germany, France, or Spain.
These business models did not work as to take over English water companies there had to be promises of action on water leakage and improvements in sewage treatment works as more houses across the country were being build. The burgeoning profits planned for continental shareholders were not materialising. The owners told the water company directors to economise and slow down capital expenditure. The Europeans left in a near panic and saw what turned out in certain cases vultures dressed as white knights.
Pension companies sound rather cuddly, they provide for peoples old age and wellbeing, but in reality they are able to manipulate the lending banks, the British government their own governments as the pension funds are usually not UK based but Canadian or in one case Antipodean. They enter the arena offering staggering investment capital, they privatise the water company and tell the board of directors of the water company to cut back investment further. Such schemes as the Thames Tideway Tunnel are running behind schedule and for that reason are costing more and in this case Thames Water is on the precipice of bankruptcy. Their owners borrowed money to pay their pension fund large dividends though they knew that Thames was in a situation where they needed further investment before they ditched their investment and left the UK ‘permanently.
Within a couple of years, the same company returned to England looking to use the same model of corporate dexterity seen at Thames. This time they were delighted to offer to pay the newly acquired company’s record fine for pollution and state they would invest a billion pounds in environmental improvements. Since then, the company has been emptying it sewers into the natural environment not just when it rains but during drought.
The Environment Agency stated yesterday that they are investigating so don’t hold your breath as the pension fund will likely have left these shores again before any action can take place against their investment.
History.
The English and Welsh have never been good in caring for their rivers and water supplies. Often it is just not thinking actions through being the reason, though in the past it was genuinely thatpeople did not know. We, the British, have also demonstrated over the years an ability to not care as someone else will sort it out for us.
In the 14th Century the town of Shrewsbury was on the border with Wales. The old town was set in the look of a large meaner of the River Severn, as it still is. The town had one bridge that allowed for travel to Wales and the other allowed access to the rest of England. The town was careful to clean its drains (sewers) and place the resultant waste into the river to be carried away. The problem for the citizens was that often the waste was put in at the side of the Welsh Bridge whilst the towns potable supply was removed down stream at the English Bridge. The resultant outbreaks of cholera and typhoid fever, often catastrophic were, after some time remedied with a change of practice with the drinking supplies being harvested from the Welsh Bridge and the sewage dropped in at the English Bridge. About a hundred years later a butcher was fined for polluting the river upstream of the Welsh Bridge with a dumping of offal and other animal remains. People do not remember where their water comes from, and they seldom care where waste goes.
In the 17th Century much of London was supplied by water sellers who delivered churns to households who could afford such amounts, the poorer citizens purchasing a scoop from a churn at a time. Good water was supplied from ponds and the headwaters of the River Fleet at Hampstead producing some of what was considered the capital’s purest supply. The New River supplied a series of conduits that supplied pumps around the centre of the city. Wells supplied most of the rest. By the 19th Century the Thames supplied some water in pipes to houses of quality but that had to be refined and filtered to such a degree the price was high but not considered drinkable. The supplies were the work of private enterprise and when at times these companies were nationalised and made the responsibility of the local authority or Corporation of the City the undertakings soon changed back as each undertaker found their costs onerous.
In one instance of an outbreak of cholera and the Broad Street Pump in Soho the pioneering Dr Snow recognised that the water from that particular pump was the source of the outbreak infecting those that partook of its water. He acted, chaining the handle and by so doing ended the outbreak. The pump though was owned by the local authority who did all they could to discredit the doctor, his research won the day.
The sewers of London for hundreds of years guaranteed to make drinking water unpalatable across the city. In the 17th Century Samual Pepys complained in his diary that his neighbour’s urine and excrement seeped from their cellar which was full. Sewers that ran under streets were few but those that did were linked to surface drains taking animal and human waste. All such drains followed the natural drainage of the city’s geography. Small streams and rivers such as the River Fleet became sewers and all drains emptied into the Thames where it was meant to flow out to the sea. Unfortunately, as the river is tidal and London is set well back in the Thames Estuary the tide ebbs and flows only slowly voiding the putrescent detritus of society to the North Sea, this meant that noxious tide remained traveling up and down with the tide and being added to continually. The Great Stink as it became know allowed the eventual creation of a sewage collection and treatment system for the Thames, but it took nearly forty years to reach near completion. Today the Thames is still having upgrades to its protection against sewage pollution.
The Future.
As I said earlier the water companies are not fit for purpose though some are better than others, It appears that the water companies might be gathered into the government to be restructured and placed under a management system that if not for profit might be cooperative in nature with the water regulator more involved in consumer need and pricing rather than looking at agreed profit margins.
As can be seen from above the water industry is constantly changing and over the last 20 years has lost its way and on the whole forgotten what their true functions are. The money market is not the sustainable route for a public utility that should carry out their duty to the public.
Harvey Wood
September 2023.
This is a personal view and may not be those of the Trustees.
