Water in England and Wales.

Introduction.

The rivers, canals, lakes and water supplies of England and Wales are starting to come under the scrutiny of a new commission investigation. The first such investigation came about in 1865 and covered the whole of Great Britain. It was produced by the Royal Commission on River Pollution and Water Supply. It sat from 1863 through till the early 1900s and published several reports. These covered many topics related to the subject including Metropolitan Water Supply, Pollution from mining and Metal Industry, via Water Supply to the Royal Palaces and the Water Supply of Great Britain. Today these reports are still of great interest and have details that would never be reported on today, many though being still relevant.

This new committee of the great and good have asked that those who have a view to contact them with it and let them have evidence. The EFRA, All Party Committee of the House of Commons is also enquiring into the water companies at the present time. They have also requested that they receive the views of all interested parties. Both groups are very much researching similar but not exactly similar areas of concern. The two committees are composed of different beings, the Commission is made up of a mix of civil servants, academics, and those from industry, whilst the EFRA committee is composed of politicians. Both groups will publish their findings towards the back end of this year.

The Water Industry.

The view of the public is that it is in chaos, especially the largest company, Thames Water, bankrupt and publicly battling its creditors. The majority of the water companies are only parts of larger entities and may be considered as stable revenue sources for those companies. The fascination of Australian investors in English water companies means they cannot stay away. Other countries also have interests, from China and Canada, the French, and several others in the privatised water industry. Few water companies are present on the London Stock Exchange.

The water industry today is only the latest of its many forms, it is also its most complex to govern. In the past companies such as the New River Company, and the Southwark Water Supply Company were much smaller entities. The population of the UK has a memory of water coming from local authorities and then water boards. They were used to paying water rates, which were based on antiquated mechanisms of pricing. The water companies realised when they were first privatised that there were several changes needing to be addressed.

People were using more water in 1989 than they were in 1974 when the water authorities came into existence and even that was greater than before the Second World War. This increase of water use was further exacerbated by a constant increase in the population. More potable water was necessary. Kielder Water was the last large-scale reservoir to be created in the 1970s and 80s. A number are being planned for now across the country, but the planning process is expensive as the population do not like to see communities displaced or loved landscapes inundated. Add the costs of turning shallow valleys into small seas to supply the population with Adam’s ale.  The water companies had the new rating system worked out as the local government ditched poll tax to base its new bills, but it was still a poor method of charging people for their water supply. The water used by each household would be fairer that the rateable value and water companies have now a majority of household are charged for their water by the cubic metre consumed. You could water your garden or fill a kettle and as a fair rate was charged for exceptional quality water.

In 1989 Britain was considered the Dirty Man of Europe, rivers were declining in quality with partially treated sewage choking many of them. In 1974 when local authorities relinquished their hold on the supply of water and the treatment of sewage this was even worse and equally acceptable, so long as ‘pure’ water came through the taps. Ten or so years before the privatisation of the water industry the population were becoming aware of the quality of rivers, swimming inn rivers even in the 1940s and 50s was known to be the source of so many children contracting polio.

The populace across the country had considered sewage as part of public health and not related to the water industry. The privatised industry though charged for it more openly and still charge the household for the treatment of every cubic metre abstracted from a tap; even though two thirds of that volume used may have been used to keep your grass green and your plants blooming.

The water industry has to outline its plans for investment to OFWAT, its regulator for its public value. It outlines need for more and better-quality water, replacement of leaking mains, alternative supplies so that nature is not disadvantaged or new reservoirs. It also has to demonstrate investment to at worst keep the environment from further degradation from sewage. Nitrates have where cost allows be stripped from discharges going to streams, rivers and hopefully the sea.

The water industry now is aware of the components of treated sewage, PFAS, micro plastics, oestrogens, drugs and pharma products amongst it.  These can all be removed at costs that make the water companies blanch. The good news is that new low-cost methods are being developed that will do this work.

The public are rightly critical of the companies whilst the senior management of these polluters are seen to get well remunerated at the expense of the environment. This having grown substantially since covid lockdowns people have had more leisure time and free swimming, water boarding or just watching rivers flow have grown increasingly popular.

The Environment Agency and Natural Resources Wales.

The Environment Agency and Natural Resources Wales are the regulators of the water environment. They are the nations’ watchdogs of pollution, water quality and up till recently many of their staff knew the waterways well. Things though have changed though. Today through retirement, changes in employment (the water industry have employed many of the most experienced staff to leader stormwater and sewer overflow remediation projects). Many staff are not replaced due to cuts in government grant in aid that have seen the Environment Agency, and its offspring Natural Resources Wales rely on other ministries and sources of funding. The Environment Agency has lost its teeth, and with them their own web site.

In the past the Agency sponsored large volumes of research, so it kept itself at the forefront of the knowledge hub. It knew its rivers intimately with staff who not just cared but had worked for years along rivers in their regions. That has gone, and it cannot be blamed on Covid! The agency has had to cope with year-on-year cuts in funding from central government. The Environment Agency has shrunk and is reliant on the water industry to admit its short comings.

In Wales, these short comings were in many instances swept under the carpet. Welsh Water Dŵr Cymru being a not-for-profit company that the resurrected Welsh water company which came out of the remains of its bankrupt forebear.

Answers.

Renationalising the water industry may be the answer that many believe will put things right again. If such is the government’s desire it needs to be done carefully and not in the old water board style. They were unable to get permission from government for new sewage treatment expenditure. It was the governments of the 1970s and 1980s that saw many rivers decline faster that privatisation was the only way to get river quality to improve.

The creation of a co-operative style of water company may be a way forward. Each customer being a member with rights as well as duties. The boards could be regional or much more local. The localisation of water supply or/and sewage treatment has found favour with some of the present-day water companies. The mega sewage works that treat conurbations may be unsustainable as they have grown too big and cannot now be remodelled to use more sustainable designs as they have no more space. New sites in local areas may be able to cut costs of treatment and at the same time discharge a higher quality discharge to streams and rivers across the country.

The regulator needs resuscitation to see its resurrection. It needs to be funded as it was. It needs to be given independence once again rather than muzzled and not allowed to criticize government. It needs its web site back that told the population what had historically happened and what was happening. Rivers need to be analysed annually not every 6 or 7 years.

Catchment planning needs to be the regulators responsibility not the role of charities. They are the responders to consultation. Do not let the inmates run the asylum. The agencies need teeth and be respected by the prospective polluter.

Recommended Articles

Verified by MonsterInsights