Cinderhill

The willows have now recovered well after so long without rain or irrigation.
The once acid lake has taken on a whole new persona this year and over the last few weeks has started to develop a distinct flora of its own across parts of the open water.

The visits have been numerous even though this time of year is quiet with the leaves having dropped and the understory dying back. Several people have asked to visit including Harworth Group and the EA.
A recent visit was arranged for SA of Harworth Group to see the progress at the site.
Whitehaven
The railway tunnel beneath Whitehaven which was shut for a new track bed to be laid has now had to close for far longer due to old mineworkings beneath the tunnel subsiding. A 300-metre length beneath the tunnel floor will need to be filled in or bridged for strength after Network Rail have ascertained the size of the void. Mine water from beneath as well as from above the tunnel has been the cause of the pollution of the harbour. We had flagged this up this concern nearly three years ago when we learnt that some of the minewater only came into the tunnel via its floor on the rising tide whilst the rest was a continuous flow from workings above and alongside the tunnel. It now appear that the local yachtsmen and retired railway engineer collaborating with us have saved a serious railway train accident in the tunnel from taking place.
Rail Track have used our advice of deploying Siltbuster of Monmouth’s technology to treat the water from the tunnel whilst survey work in the progressed. For one month the harbour has been free from pollution and it was hoped this would continue until the final solution was put into place next year. This was though not to be as on the 30th September a press release was put out by Network Rail stating that the treatment was being switched off due to cost until further work commenced in possibly April 2026. We witnessed the harbour return to its red colour over a four-hour period that day.

11.00 on 30th September 2025

12.30 0n 30th September 2025

14.30 on 30th September 2025
The return of pollution has been agreed with the Environment Agency.
A representative from the Harbour Authority attending a meeting whilst the harbour was becoming polluted again took our breath away when they said that we need not worry as the best minds were working on the solution and we will be told what it is to be done in a little while once funding is secured from Parliament.
The Trust was asked to attend a Taskforce meeting on Friday 10th October when the Mining Remediation Authority outlined the plan to discharge the pollution running again from the Bransty Beck into the harbour to be discharged directly to the beach between high and low water. This is a pragmatic approach that will need to be licenced by the local authority, English Heritage and the Environment Agency and receive agreed funding from the three ministries involved, DEFRA, Energy and Transport.

10th October 2025
See appendices I, II, III.
Ballindalloch and the River Spey

We were invited to attend and speal at a special meeting of the Planning and Regulatory Committee of Moray Council on 8th/9th October. Our evidence and supplementary briefing of our concerns alongside more than 160 other objections did in this instance encourage the councillors to refuse the planning application. The Green Hydrogen plant had a grant of over £3,000,000 from the Scottish Government to establish such sites across Scotland and this project had Moray Council officials’ support. The scheme was refused permission after a final debate of several hours.
See appendix IV.
South Downs National Park Authority Report on Water Quality of Rivers

We were asked to talk on various BBC and other media about this report which appears to be one of several appearing across the country. The Rivers Trusts and Wildlife Trusts have conducted a lot of citizen science projects over the last few years with several universities including York and Brighton.
South Downs River Report Spinoff Issues.
Catchment Based Approach groups (CaBA), CaSTCo’s (Catchment Systems Thinking Cooperative) and National Parks Support Group. The Rivers Trust with the Environment Agency have set up these bodies across much of England and Wales and shortly in Northern Ireland. We have asked to be allowed to attend some of the groups but are not needed by the Environment Agency as we do not attract government or European funding or have another form of substantial income stream, nor are we riparian owners.
Rivers Itchen and Test.
These two rivers / chalk streams have over the years become the focus of a huge amount of financial commitment from the EA. All chalk streams across the UK are now being focused on by the Rivers and Wildlife Trusts and others such as Wild Fish.
Walsall Wood Colliery Historic Liquid Wate Disposal.
Research is ongoing into apparent seepages appearing along and adjacent to fault lines around the area, some of which are joining up in leachate streams from other historic landfill operations.
Public Access to Help or Advice.
This Autumn has seen us busier than ever with questions and pollution questions. We have been contacted by individuals and groups from Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and England plus some others from France, Spain, and Croatia.
The Northern Irish concerns were mainly but not exclusively Loch Earne. Scotland was regarding fish and wildfowl mortalities, whilst Welsh re mainly regarding minewater pollutions in various guises. England’s high number was that no one in the Environment Agency seemed to care when pollutions were reported to them and we were able to advise and in some instances just listen as some find pollution highly distressing. Sewage and sewage derived waste after the dry summer ended saw several stormwater drains flush out a cornucopia of nasties.
The European contacts were mainly about minewater pollution and contaminated land. No one went away without detailed advice.
Hoole Bank.
Information gathering is still taking place, and the local authority is still in contact with us regarding sharing data once it is available.
Commonside Waste Tip.
We are awaiting action from the Environment Agency to supply their thoughts to the local authority. The Environment Department is somewhat frustrated by the EA’s lack of action due to priority policy changes taking place nationally. Much of the EA focus is on development and flood risk at the moment.
Mexborough Landfill Site.
The Trust wrote a report for Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council in July 2010 on the Hydrogeological nature of a closed landfill site at Mexborough. The present council, Doncaster City Council have asked for it to be reviewed and updated. We have outlined the work involved and await agreement.
Cornish Tin/Lithium and Other Development in Cornwall and Devon.
South Crofty.
Industrial heritage sites are under perceived major threats along with possible water quality concerns. Councillors from both county councils and several district councils have contacted us. Briefings have taken place regarding the legal aspects of opening new mines alongside other information regarding tailings facilities, pumped minewater and its treatment. The statutory bodies seem not to be willing to get involved with this side of things.
Clean Rivers Trust/Clean Rivers Campaign.
The Trust’s original name was Clean Rivers Campaign which the Charity Commission required us to change before getting charitable status, though today the Women’s Institute, the Rivers Trust and Plastic Soup (in Europe) are all using Clean Rivers Campaign without a thought of its origin and/or a nod in our direction.
I have been asked on several occasions over the last year if I work for the Rivers Trust or Women’s Institute and have to say that we were formed before clean rivers were fashionable and it was our original names that gave rise to what today is a growing cacophony of people demanding better water quality and demonstrating that need with citizen science but not wanting to demonstrate that there are answers available.
To demonstrate the need for clean rivers is great but to remember who it is who will need to pay for that clean up. which is the public as we are the polluter, who wishes for what gives rise to the pollution. Clean Rivers Trust looks to bring about that change sustainably and affordably without recourse to politics or lobbying, though we will advise.
West Norfolk Borough Council.
Councillor Charles Joice, an old friend of the Trust contacted us regarding our views on a planning matter regarding the proposed upgrading of a water treatment works at Palm Paper, a recycled paper manufacturer on the Saddlebow Road Industrial Estate, Kings Lynn.

(Councillor Charles Joice involved us in the issues of contaminated land in and around Kings Lynn in 1991/2. Those sites included the long-closed West Norfolk Farmers Fertilizer factory and the adjacent derelict gas works site. In 1996 we helped him establish clarity regarding health issues related to a chemical works in North Lynn and the health of shellfish on the nearby sandbanks in the Wash.
Mining Remediation Authority.
We are talking to the MRA about lithium and other rare earths that may be present in minewater discharges. This ties into work we carried out with John Tate and ERM in the mid-1990s regarding high saline discharges in the Polish coal mining regions.
Imperial College.
The ceramics project has been terminated by Imperial College and has been taken on by Fali Omodudu who was working for them and the project though based in London is now in conjunction with Belfast University. We have been in contact regarding areas of ceramic chemistry and body formulars.
Alicja Biala.

Alicja’s artwork relating to minewater and other acidic environments was on exhibition both at the Museum of Contemporary Art in Krakow and at the Berntson Bhattacharjee Gallery in London.
The catalogue to her work published by the Museum of Contemporary Art is out now with HW’s contribution, a short essay on acid minewater.
A further exhibition of her work was held at the Berntson Bhattacharjee Gallery, Berners Street, London during November at the first Soho Art Fair held this Autumn in London.
Forest of Dean, Position of Deputy Gaveller Vacancy.
The role of Deputy Gaveller having fallen vacant and with no one available to take on the role at present HW was put forward as having the knowledge needed to carry out the role temporarily until a replacement was appointed.
This idea was later dropped by those putting it forward due to HW’s commitments and age!
Meetings/Conferences
1/Christian Wolkersdorfer workshops in Germany.
2/Mining Remediation Authority and Natural Resources Wales in Cardiff
4/Welsh Government Roundtable, Cardiff.
University of Exeter (Cornwall Campus).
We have been invited to take part in a project ‘Water pollution knowledge exchange and awareness research project in Cornwall. Initial discussions are to take place before Christmas with the first meeting on the 11th December. There appears to be a lack of knowledge about much that took place at CSM in the 1990s and early 2000s also regarding the projects around Wheel Jane and the build up to the pollution event in 1991/2.
Fuel Spill Digester and Nitrate Digester.
University of Nottingham and CRT are working on several investigations into the abilities of these products for the company that markets them.
One, a manure-based project is to be conducted at Linton prior to Christmas.
East Staffordshire Trent Mersey Canal.
Mike Wood the architect who has carried out design work for the Trust in the past, namely in the Carnon Valley in Cornwall, Annesley Nottinghamshire, Ethiopia sewage plans for Addis Ababa and Aba Samule Reservoir (both used successfully by the Chinese), and designed simple shadufs in Uganda, has asked us to help on a possible conservation project on the East Staffordshire Council section of the Tent Mersey Canal.
Other News.
Laurence’s son, a student at University of Nottingham won a national prize for his railway photographs and has had them exhibited at several stations across the metropolis.

Railway Photographic Society Special Award – credit Marnix van Kampen-Brooks© (Photo:
©: Marnix van Kampen- Brooks)
Ceramics Facilities.
The Trust has its new ceramics laboratory/workshop in place. This will be used to explore various uses of clay-based forms and surface treatments to capture pollutants and house bacteria.
COP31
The next COP conference will be held in Antalya, Turkiye between the 7th and 20th November 2026. The Trust has already received an invitation to take part in an official fringe event. More details will be known by the next Trustees meeting.
Appendices:
I
IWhitehaven tunnel repair update for passengers and residents
Region & Route:
Passengers and residents are being advised of long-term plans for the Cumbrian Coast Line after the closure of Whitehaven tunnel.
Following the discovery of historic mine workings ahead of a planned track renewal specialist engineers have been working to deliver a lasting solution for the line.
The extent of the work needed means Bransty tunnel, between Whitehaven and Corkickle is expected to be closed until Spring 2026.
Network Rail is working closely with train operator, Northern, to keep passengers on trains as much as possible.
Passengers can travel across much of the Cumbrian Coast Line, except through the circa 1km tunnel that takes trains through Whitehaven into Corkickle.
Rail replacement bus services are in operation to transport passengers between the seaside resorts while the work is ongoing.
Phil James, Network Rail’s North West route director, said: “The safety of passengers and staff is our number one priority and I understand that this is really disappointing news for passengers in this part of Cumbria. Our experts have spent a great deal of time examining the data and having it reviewed by peers in the industry. They all agree that this is the right thing to do while further investigation can be carried out and a specialist plan put in place.”
Matt Rice, Chief Operating Officer for Northern said: “We are sorry for the frustration that this disruption is causing, and we are working hard to keep customers moving whilst work takes place inside the tunnel. Trains are running to Whitehaven on the northern side of the tunnel, and we are now also running trains to Corkickle on the southern side.
”We’d like to remind customers to plan ahead and check before you travel, as journeys may take longer whilst the tunnel is closed. Details of train services and rail replacement buses can be found on the Northern website – northernrailway.co.uk.”
Network Rail engineers began scheduled survey work on 25 July 2025, preparing for planned track and drainage upgrades. However, investigations identified that the tunnel floor needs significant reinforcement to support heavy machinery required for the improvements, with the discovery of historic mining activity complicating the engineering challenge.
The extent of strengthening work needed means the tunnel cannot safely reopen until completion of comprehensive repairs. Specialist engineers are developing detailed plans to address the ground conditions, with the tunnel expected to remain closed until Spring 2026.
Additional ground investigations will continue around the tunnel to build a complete picture of subsurface conditions. The work forms part of broader infrastructure improvements designed to enhance reliability on this vital transport link serving Cumbrian coastal communities.
For more information about the work, visit the Network Rail webpage.
Notes to Editors
Bransty tunnel is a 1km railway tunnel on the Cumbrian Coast Line between Whitehaven and Corkickle stations. The tunnel has been closed since 25 July 2025 for safety reasons following engineering surveys.
The closure affects a key section of the Cumbrian Coast Line, which connects communities along England’s western coastline and supports both local residents and the region’s tourism economy.
Network Rail is continuing to work with the Whitehaven Harbour Commissioners, the Environment Agency and the Mining Remediation Authority, as part of a working group focussed on delivering a feasibility report, to provide funders with possible solutions on diverting ochreous water away from entering Queens Dock and the Bransty Beck culvert.
The treatment plant will be in place during the work only due to environmental permits and funding.
II
Letter from Network Rail
Dear all,
As you are aware, our additional ground investigations – to better understand the sub-surface conditions in the area around Bransty tunnel ahead of our specialist cement void filling work – started this week. Once complete, the previously planned track and drainage renewal can start, and then trains will resume services through the tunnel after Spring next year.
We are nearing the end of the on-site part of these ground investigations, and will be moving to the design stage to work up the final delivery plan. While we do that, we won’t be physically on-site investigating the tunnel. This means that the pumping system – which is filtering the mine water from the tunnel into the harbour as part of permit conditions from the Environment Agency for the track and drainage renewal – is no longer required at this time. As such, we plan to switch off the pumps tomorrow – Tuesday 30 September.
With the filtering system proving to be effective in the harbour, we fully recognise switching it off will not be popular. The reason why we have discounted the filtering system as a long-term measure to address the water colour is down to the prohibitive cost. Running the pumping system until the very end of the work in Spring 2026 would cost additional £4.8m. We’d need to find this money from other sources which would significantly impact our safety critical renewal and maintenance work across the NW. That said, the pumps will remain in situ and be switched on again, as required by the Environment Agency, when we start our remediation works in the tunnel in early November this year.
All of this goes to highlight the important of our collective efforts on the Whitehaven Harbour Feasibility Working Group (WHFWG) and we look forward to reviewing the feasibility report when it is ready.
With thanks
Head of Communications
North West route
III
Invitation from MP.
| You are cordially invited to the next meeting of the Whitehaven Harbour Taskforce, chaired by Josh MacAlister MP. The sole item on the agenda will be a presentation by the Mining Remediation Authority on the feasibility study that has been carried out into permanent solutions to divert the water from the harbour and a discussion to gauge views on the options available. The views of the taskforce will then feed into the next ministerial meeting, to be scheduled later in October. |
| When Friday Oct 10, 2025 ⋅ 2pm – 3pm (United Kingdom Time) |
| Location The Solway Hall Whitehaven Civic Hall, Lowther St, Whitehaven, CA28 7SH, England View map |
| Guests Josh MacAlister OBE MP – organizer clyne@co-lab.engineering hayes.chris4@googlemail.com andy.morritt@miningremediation.gov.uk charlottedawson@whitehavenmarina.co.uk clerk@whitehaventowncouncil.co.uk deanne.shallcross@whitehavenhc.org.uk Cllr Emma Williamson hwoop@aol.com joseph.ghayouba@cumberland.gov.uk Julia Draycon karl.melville@cumberland.gov.uk mark.telford@forth.uk.com peter.miles@environment-agency.gov.uk raymond.gill16@yahoo.co.uk tim.marples@miningremediation.gov.uk tonytaylor@marinaprojects.com |
| Reply for hwoop@aol.com YES |
IV
Ballindalloch
Economy, Enterprise and Operations
Acting Principal Planning Officer
Moray Council
Dr Harvey Wood
15 October 2025
Dear Sir(s)/Madam
Town and Country Planning (Scotland) 1997
Representations on behalf of: Dr Harvey Wood
Construction of a 70 MWe electrolytic hydrogen production facility and associated ancillary infrastructure including water supply and wastewater pipeline on Land South Of Marypark Ballindalloch Moray
I refer to your letter submitting representations in respect of the above development and write to advise you that the application has been refused.
Your representations were taken into consideration in determining this application.
Should you wish to view the decision notice a copy is held on file at Moray Council offices in Elgin and in accordance with the Council’s agreed scheme of charges, decision notices can be obtained at a cost. Alternatively, a copy of the Council’s decision and report prepared in support of the decision can be inspected on the Council’s website at http:/publicaccess.moray.gov.uk/eplanning
Yours faithfully
Andrew Miller
Acting Principal Planning Officer
VI

