First, I must state I like beavers. I was appalled when it was reported in the newspapers that 80 had been killed in Scotland in 2019/20. I also like salmon, other fish, and most other aquatic creature to a greater or lesser degree. It has been brought to my attention that rivers are at a crossroad of their future ecological evolution.
The great shout that is constantly being heard is that rivers are to be rewilded, bring back the beaver, natural leaky dams that hold back flood waters. At the same time, we hear that weirs and other fluvial obstructions should be removed to encourage sea trout and salmon to enter rivers and pass easily upstream to spawn. This will also help the spread of genetic variation along whole lengths of rivers. The logic sounds wonderful up to a point. At that point it gets a little murky. Are we at this point replacing one form of fluvial obstacle with another; all be it a natural form rather than ones built of bricks and mortar or concrete?
Throw into this mix that some concrete weirs are needed by the Environment Agency, SEPA, National Resources Wales or any other organisation with statutory responsibilities. Other structures obstructing the river flow are protected due to their heritage value, pound locks, watermills, and other structures. Such double standards can be driven by fishery owners whilst others by flood engineers or other interest groups.
There are many financial and philosophical investors in rivers from water companies to swimmers, boaters, fisherpeople, anglers, idlers, artists, ecologists: the list goes on and on and at the end are you and me, the general public. I care as I like rivers; the sound of water, the birds, fish, plants, everything about a river is likable even floods teach you knew things, I know because I lived by a river for years and it did come to call.
It may be time to start this debate before too much cash and energy starts to show the wrong side of environmental care.
Harvey Wood.

